SUNBURY — Recent sampling of adult smallmouth bass on the West Branch of the Susquehanna River has shown an high prevalence of melanosis, according to a Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission biologist.
Is this a result of pollution?
“We noticed it in a few of our sampling locations,” Geoffrey Smith said. “We were out almost every night over the last two months and once we started to see (fish with melanosis), we saw it in almost every survey.” Smith could not provide information on the cause of the melanosis, the abnormal or excessive production of melanin in the skin or other tissue. Pathologists from the U.S. Geological Survey and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service who examined the fish tissues agreed that the smallmouth had melanosis, Smith said. “As far as a cause, I am not certain there has been any movement on that front.” The concern is whether the melanosis represents melanoma, which would be skin cancer in wild fish. “If it does,” said William Yingling, a retired physician and avid fisherman from Freeburg, “we need to know why they have cancer. We really need to know why so many wild fish in the Susquehanna have begun showing up with these black spots in large numbers since March 2010, almost four years ago.” Yingling said he has fished the Susquehanna watershed since he was a teenager and never saw the condition in smallmouth bass until 2010.
“I fish now exclusively between Winfield and Port Trevorton,” Yingling said. “Twenty to 25 percent of the smallmouth bass I catch over 15 inches in length, older fish, have some degree of pigmentation.” Smith, the biologist, did not say how many smallmouth were studied or what techniques were used to examine the tissues. “We just submitted some more fish for analysis last week to continue to document the condition and keep an eye on the pathology to see if anything is changing,” Smith said. Four different sets of tissue are being analyzed, those from spring 2012, fall 2012, and this spring and fall, Smith said. “I have not heard about the fish from spring 2013 yet, but that is a much larger sample size so there is likely more information there than in the others,” Smith said. Different types of environmental data have been collected in the watershed in 2013 for varied efforts, Smith said. The U.S. Geological Survey and state Department of Environmental Protection have sampled sediment and water contaminants throughout the basin in 2013 as part of studies related to smallmouth bass investigations, he said. Sample collection is ending for 2013. Data will be examined over the winter, Smith said. “With all the different, yet cooperative, work going on during 2013,” Smith said, “this was a heavily studied stretch of river.” Yingling claims Smith did not use the newest staining techniques for the diagnosis of melanoma. “It can be very difficult to differentiate between benign melanin deposits and malignant melanoma,” he said. Looking for causes, and finding none An expert in the field, British biologist Michael Sweet examined coral trout from the Great Barrier Reef in Australia that have black spots much like those on the smallmouth bass in the Susquehanna River. Sweet used newer staining techniques for melanoma and reported that some of the pigment changes represented superficial malignant melanoma. “I do not believe enough specimens have been done on the Susquehanna smallmouth,” Yingling said. “Newer cancer staining techniques have not been used to diagnose possible melanoma and I do not believe pathologists familiar with the diagnosis of melanoma have looked at the tissue.” Susquehanna River smallmouth bass have 30-plus different organic chemicals that have been found in their bodies, Yingling said. “It is my belief,” Yingling said, “that the chemical pollutants to which the Susquehanna smallmouth bass are exposed are creating this pigmentation problem. It is a serious problem and if it is cancer, then it is very significant because many Pennsylvanians are drinking the water and being exposed to the water containing these chemicals.” More needs to be done to identify the pigmentation and its cause, he said. “We should know much more after four years.” n Email comments to firstname.lastname@example.org.